Pickup My Sugar Pie

Order online or call today to place your order and pickup your favorite My Sugar Pie at our ship in Zionsville, Indiana.

Order Indiana's Food Gift for Pickup Today

Simply order online and select “Pickup at ‘My Sugar Pie’ Shop in Zionsville and we’ll have your pie ready for pickup within 48 hours of your order confirmation.
order now
Fruit Pies
Cream Pies
Other Favorites

Purchasing Our Pies

Our pies are available for purchase online, by phone at 317-733-8717 or in our Zionsville shop.

However you prefer to order, please allow 48 hours to schedule your pie pick up. Pies are shipped Monday and Tuesday. Please place your pie order one week before the day of shipment. Please note: cream pies with meringue topping cannot be shipped.

Where to Buy

In addition to our pie shop, you can find My Sugar Pie at the Zionsville Farmer’s Market on Saturday mornings from 8am-11am, May to September.

My Sugar Pie is also available by the slice at select locations throughout the Indianapolis metropolitan area:

Cobb.GrillSNMCobblestone Grill

Harry-IzzysHarry & Izzy’s Downtown

St-Elmos-Web-LogoSt. Elmo Steak House

Harry-IzzysHarry & Izzy’s Northside

Order your Thanksgiving Pies by calling the shop 317-733-8717 or Stop By! Online Ordering is NOT available for Thanksgiving Week Orders! Dismiss