Pie Menu

Not all pie flavors are available for shipping. 

Fruit Pies

 

Mom’s Original Dutch Apple 34
Apple Lattice 33
Dutch Blackberry 36
Blackberry Lattice 35
Dutch Black Raspberry 38
Black Raspberry Lattice 37
Dutch Go Blueberry 34
Go Blueberry Lattice 33
Dutch Cherry 34
Cherry Lattice 33
Dutch Mixed Berry 36
Mixed Berry Lattice 35
Dutch Peach 32
Peach Lattice 31
Peach Praline 34
Dutch Peach Blueberry 33
Peach Blueberry Lattice 32
Dutch Pineapple 29
Pineapple Lattice 28
Dutch Red Raspberry Kisser 36
Red Raspberry Kisser Lattice 35
Dutch Rhubarb 32
Rhubarb Lattice 31
Dutch Strawberry 32
Strawberry Lattice 31
Dutch Strawberry Rhubarb 34
Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice 33

 

Cream Pies

All Cream Pies Must Be Picked Up After 2pm

**We do not offer meringue toppings on our cream pies

 

Banana Cream 34
Butterscotch Cream 34
Chocolate Cream 36
Chocolate & PB Cream 34
Coconut Cream 34
Lemon Cream 34
My Elvis Pie Banana & PB Cream 36
Peanut Butter Cream 34

 

Other Favorites

 

French Silk 36
Hoosier Sugar Cream 32
I Love You Chocolate Chip 30
Mint Chocolate Chip 32
Key Lime Graham Cracker Crust 34
Key Lime Pastry Crust 33
My Kentucky Pie 36
Pecan 34
Pumpkin 32
Pumpkin Praline 34
S’more Pie 32
Brownie PIe 34
Red Velvet Pie 34
Confetti Birthday Pie – White or Pink Icing 34
Take & Bake Quiche – Ham & Cheese 34