Pie Menu

Not all pie flavors are available for shipping.

Mom’s Original Dutch Apple	34
Apple Lattice	33
Dutch Blackberry	36
Blackberry Lattice	35
Dutch Black Raspberry	38
Black Raspberry Lattice	37
Dutch Go Blueberry	34
Go Blueberry Lattice	33
Dutch Cherry	34
Cherry Lattice	33
Dutch Mixed Berry	36
Mixed Berry Lattice	35
Dutch Peach	32
Peach Lattice	31
Peach Praline	34
Dutch Peach Blueberry	33
Peach Blueberry Lattice	32
Dutch Pineapple	29
Pineapple Lattice	28
Dutch Red Raspberry Kisser	36
Red Raspberry Kisser Lattice	35
Dutch Rhubarb	32
Rhubarb Lattice	31
Dutch Strawberry	32
Strawberry Lattice	31
Dutch Strawberry Rhubarb	34
Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice	33

All Cream Pies Must Be Picked Up After 2pm

**We do not offer meringue toppings on our cream pies

French Silk	36
Hoosier Sugar Cream	32
I Love You Chocolate Chip	30
Mint Chocolate Chip	32
Key Lime Graham Cracker Crust	34
Key Lime Pastry Crust	33
My Kentucky Pie	36
Pecan	34
Pumpkin	32
Pumpkin Praline	34
S’more Pie	32
Brownie PIe	34
Red Velvet Pie	34
Confetti Birthday Pie – White or Pink Icing	34
Take & Bake Quiche – Ham & Cheese	34