NOTE: All online pie orders must be submitted 48-72 hours in advance of pick-up time.
  • Greenwood store is not yet taking orders online.
  • There is no additional charge with pies requested for local pickup, but they MUST be picked-up within 24 hours from the requested date.
  • Pickup times: Mon - Fri Noon 'til 6 pm or Sat Noon 'til 3pm

Online Gift Certificate


Out of stock



Share the joy of My Sugar Pie by creating your own online gift certificate in any amount from $25 – $1,000 redeemable online at!


There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

My Sugar Pie Zionsville and Greenwood are taking Pie Orders for your Easter and Mother’s Day events! Dismiss