“The Indiana Food Gift”


order now

“Pity the folks who have only sampled rhubarb as strawberry’s costar — then send them a slice from My Sugar Pie.”

order now

Our Sugar Cream Pie is “one of The Best Mail-Order Pies in the United States.”

Country Living

msp-ph-logoStop by our shop at 40 East Pine Street, Zionsville and enjoy a slice or take home a whole pie to share with friends and family. The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes more than 40 different pies – all handmade, with a light, crispy crust that is from owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe.


Find My Sugar Pie By The Slice At These Fine Restaurants

Hours of Operation:

Matt and Lisa celebrated with My Sugar Pie! Congratulations and Thanks! ... See MoreSee Less

1 day ago  ·  

View on Facebook

Thanks Nicholson Orthodontics for gifting My Sugar Pie!!!Our friends at Nicholson Orthodontics surprised us with an early Thanksgiving gift. I think it’s safe to say we liked it! 😳 My Sugar Pie never disappoints. 🥧 💕 Thank you!! ... See MoreSee Less

4 weeks ago  ·  

View on Facebook

Order your Holiday Pies by calling the shop 317-733-8717 or Stop By! Online Ordering is NOT available for Christmas Week Orders! Dismiss