“The Indiana Food Gift”


order now

“Pity the folks who have only sampled rhubarb as strawberry’s costar — then send them a slice from My Sugar Pie.”

order now

Our Sugar Cream Pie is “one of The Best Mail-Order Pies in the United States.”

Country Living

msp-ph-logoPlease stop by our shop at 40 East Pine Street, Zionsville and enjoy a slice or take home a whole pie to share with friends and family.
The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes more than 40 different pies – all handmade, with a light, crispy crust that is from owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe.

My Sugar Pie is also available by the slice at these fine restaurants:
Auberge, Zionsville;
Cobblestone, Zionsville;
Harry & Izzy’s Downtown Indy;
Harry & Izzy’s Northside Indy;
JRazzo’s, Carmel;
JRazzo’s 2, Westfield;
Mimi’s Blue Meatballs, Carmel;
Mimi’s Blue Meatballs, Downtown Indy;
Provisions, Indy;
St. Elmo Steak House, Indy;
Uptown Café, Bloomington; and
Woodland Terrace of Carmel.

My Sugar Pie will have special pickup and shipment schedules for Christmas Week and New Year’s Eve Week!

We will be honoring our special pickup schedule throughout Christmas week and New Year’s Eve Week.  If you would like to order pies for your celebrations, then call us 317-733-8717.  Happy Holidays!

My Sugar Pie will be closed for a Tiny Baking Break from Monday, January 8-Tuesday, January 16, 2018. Happy New Year!