Pie Events & Catering

Thank you for your interest in having My Sugar Pie at your special event!  We do wedding pies, pies for large corporate events, and pies for other large venues.

Some helpful information:

  • Our whole pies serve 8-10 people each.
  • If delivery is needed, we ask for a $50 delivery charge per delivery to your event if the delivery destination is within our local area.  In store pick up is available for both pie shops.
  • We normally will do a tasting to determine the flavors you would like and the numbers of pies that you need.  We can do custom pies also. We do not recommend meringue top cream pies because they are very difficult to transport and are very delicate.
  • We do not offer special pricing for large orders.  No bulk order discounts.
  • We will need your contact person’s name and phone number.
  • We will need your event date and location.
  • Once you book with My Sugar Pie we ask that half of the total cost is paid at booking.  The remainder will be due one week before the event.

Event Request Form

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

Upcoming Events

Apr
26
Sat
1:00 pm Strawberry Shortcake Class @ My Sugar Pie
Strawberry Shortcake Class @ My Sugar Pie
Apr 26 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
Strawberry Shortcake Class @ My Sugar Pie
Homemade Strawberry Shortcake and our Fresh Whipped Cream are perfect for a Spring Saturday.  Join our pastry chefs and make them in our My Sugar Pie kitchen! $40 per person includes what you make, baking[...]
May
3
Sat
8:00 am My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
May 3 @ 8:00 am – 11:30 am
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers Market @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie Every Saturday at Carmel Farmers Market 2025
1:00 pm Mother’s Tea @ My Sugar Pie
Mother’s Tea @ My Sugar Pie
May 3 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
Mother's Tea @ My Sugar Pie
Bring Mom and Enjoy Pie Tarts, Scones, Clotted Cream, Quiche, Finger Sandwiches, Petit Butter Cakes, Pots of English Teas and MORE in our little cottage bakery in Downtown Zionsville!  Call the shop to sign up[...]
May
10
Sat
8:00 am My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
May 10 @ 8:00 am – 11:30 am
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers Market @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie Every Saturday at Carmel Farmers Market 2025
May
17
Sat
8:00 am My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers ... @ Carmel Farmer's Market
May 17 @ 8:00 am – 11:30 am
My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers Market @ Carmel Farmer's Market
My Sugar Pie Every Saturday at Carmel Farmers Market 2025

Please choose a pickup date before finalizing your order.
Order Your Easter Pies for Pick up on Friday, April 18th and Saturday, April 19th!

X