About Kelly

Kelly has a B.S. in Education and a Masters in Literacy. She spent 11 years teaching before she decided to stay at home to raise her two boys.

Kelly & Mom

Years of baking pies for friends and family led Kelly to follow a dream and start ‘My Sugar Pie’-the same nickname she and her mom had given to her children.

Kelly is known by many to be a dedicated mother and a loving wife. Her wonderful pies and friendly disposition have combined with her entrepreneurial spirit to be a recipe for success.

Kelly learned the craft of pie baking from her mom, Marge McLain who is an inspiration and constant support.

Please choose a pickup date before finalizing your order.

 My Sugar Pie is 18! Slice Special:  3 for $18!  New Hours:  OPEN Tuesday thru Saturday 8am-4pm, CLOSED Sunday & Monday!  Happy Sweet 2026!

X