Spring Afternoon Tea

Spring Afternoon Tea

by | Jan 2, 2026

Enjoy Pie Tarts, Scones, Clotted Cream, Mini Quiches and a Pot of Tea in our little cottage bakery in Downtown Zionsville!  Call the shop to sign up for a table, 317-733-8717, $40 per person, Ages 5+, ( up to 4 people can be seated at a table for a reservation)
Spring Afternoon Tea

Spring Afternoon Tea

by | Jan 2, 2026

Enjoy Pie Tarts, Scones, Clotted Cream, Mini Quiches and a Pot of Tea in our little cottage bakery in Downtown Zionsville!  Call the shop to sign up for a table, 317-733-8717, $40 per person, Ages 5+, ( up to 4 people can be seated at a table for a reservation)
Donut Baking Class

Donut Baking Class

by | Jan 2, 2026

We are making and baking the sweetest donuts in our My Sugar Pie kitchen! $40 per person includes what you make, 2 baking stations, a shop tour, a pie tasting, and a drink.  For Ages 8 and up!

Please choose a pickup date before finalizing your order.

Pie Love Slice Special:  3 for $14! Good thru March 7th.  New Hours:  OPEN Tuesday thru Saturday 8am-4pm, CLOSED Sunday & Monday!  Happy Sweet 2026!

Got it!
X