Pie Events & Catering

Thank you for your interest in having My Sugar Pie at your special event!  We do wedding pies, pies for large corporate events, and pies for other large venues.

Some helpful information:

  • Our whole pies serve 8-10 people each.
  • If delivery is needed, we ask for a $50 delivery charge per delivery to your event if the delivery destination is within our local area.  In store pick up is available for both pie shops.
  • We normally will do a tasting to determine the flavors you would like and the numbers of pies that you need.  We can do custom pies also. We do not recommend meringue top cream pies because they are very difficult to transport and are very delicate.
  • We do not offer special pricing for large orders.  No bulk order discounts.
  • We will need your contact person’s name and phone number.
  • We will need your event date and location.
  • Once you book with My Sugar Pie we ask that half of the total cost is paid at booking.  The remainder will be due one week before the event.

Event Request Form

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

Upcoming Events

Jan
23
Fri
8:00 am National PIE Day is January 23rd! @ My Sugar Pie
National PIE Day is January 23rd! @ My Sugar Pie
Jan 23 @ 8:00 am – 4:00 pm
National PIE Day is January 23rd! @ My Sugar Pie
3 Slices for $18 to celebrate My Sugar Pie’s Sweet 18th Anniversary! 50% Off all Clearance Winter Retail Items! Come into Pie Shop for a chance to Win a Free Pie!
Jan
24
Sat
1:00 pm Pie Pop Class @ My Sugar Pie
Pie Pop Class @ My Sugar Pie
Jan 24 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
Pie Pop Class @ My Sugar Pie
Bake these Heart-Shaped Pie Pops that are not only fun to make but are fun to gift!  Enjoy some sweet time in our Zionsville Pie Kitchen with our bakers making these pie pops.  Cost is[...]
Jan
31
Sat
1:00 pm Sweet Heart Sugar Cookie Class @ My Sugar Pie
Sweet Heart Sugar Cookie Class @ My Sugar Pie
Jan 31 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
Sweet Heart Sugar Cookie Class @ My Sugar Pie
Make and Decorate Sweet Heart Sugar Cookies!  Bake with the Best at My Sugar Pie! $40 per person, Ages 8+, Call the shop to Sign Up 317-733-8717.
Feb
14
Sat
1:00 pm Red Velvet Heart Whoopie Pie Class ... @ My Sugar Pie
Red Velvet Heart Whoopie Pie Class ... @ My Sugar Pie
Feb 14 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
Red Velvet Heart Whoopie Pie Class for Couples @ My Sugar Pie
Heart-Shaped Red Velvet Whoopie Pies are fun to make with your valentine or galentine!  $40 per person includes what you make, baking stations, a shop tour, a pie tasting, and a drink.  For Ages 8[...]
Feb
21
Sat
1:00 pm S’more Scone Class @ My Sugar Pie
S’more Scone Class @ My Sugar Pie
Feb 21 @ 1:00 pm – 2:30 pm
S'more Scone Class @ My Sugar Pie
S’more Baking Love! Learn and Do in the heart of Zionsville in our Cozy Kitchen!  Make, Bake, and Take S’more Scones!  Call the shop to sign up 317-733-8717, $40 per person, Ages 8 and UP.[...]

Please choose a pickup date before finalizing your order.

 My Sugar Pie is 18! Slice Special:  3 for $18!  New Hours:  OPEN Tuesday thru Saturday 8am-4pm, CLOSED Sunday & Monday!  Happy Sweet 2026!

X