Key Lime Graham Cracker Crust

Bake with the Best at My Sugar Pie! Our Pastry Chefs will guide you through making and baking Heart-shaped (Or Football-shaped) Pie Pops to take home! Learn and Do in the Heart of Zionsville! Call[...]

Make and Decorate Edible Valentine Sweet Heart Sugar Cookies!  Bake with the Best at My Sugar Pie! $30 per person, Ages 5+, Call the shop to Sign Up 317-733-8717.

Make, Bake, Fill, and Take delicate French Macaroons!  Our Pastry Chefs will guide you through every step! Call the shop to sign up 317-733-8717, $30 per person, Ages 14+

Make Homemade Marshmallows and Hot Cocoa in our Warm & Cozy Kitchen!  Bake with the Best at My Sugar Pie!  Call the shop to sign up 317-733-8717, $30 per person, Ages 5+

My Sugar Pie doesn’t bake Gluten Free Pies but our Pastry Chefs can teach you how to make the BEST Gluten Free Brownies!  Make, Bake, Ice, and Take these Delicious Brownies Home!  Call the shop[...]