Wait! Before you order!
If you need a pie for Christmas & New Year’s, use the button below for a special order.
Need a pie any other day? Use this page!
Cream Pies
All Cream Pies Must Be Picked Up After 2pm
**We do not offer meringue toppings on our cream pies
Despite Image Size Differences, All Pies Are Approximately 10″ Diameter
-
Banana CreamWhipped Cream
$34.00 -
Butterscotch CreamWhipped Cream
$34.00 -
Chocolate CreamWhipped Cream
$36.00 -
Chocolate & Peanut Butter CreamWhipped Cream
$34.00 -
Coconut CreamWhipped Cream
$34.00 -
French Silk & Whipped Cream
$36.00 -
Lemon Cream Whipped Cream
$34.00 -
My Elvis PB & Banana CreamWhipped Cream
$36.00 -
Peanut Butter CreamWhipped Cream
$34.00
Fruit Pies
-
Apple Lattice Crust
$33.00 -
“Mom’s Original” Dutch Apple
$34.00 -
Mixed Berry Lattice Crust
$35.00 -
Dutch Mixed Berry
$36.00 -
Blackberry Lattice Crust
$35.00 -
Dutch Blackberry
$36.00 -
“Go Blueberry” Lattice Crust
$33.00 -
Dutch “Go BLUEberry”
$34.00 -
Cherry Lattice Crust
$33.00 -
Dutch Cherry
$34.00 -
Peach Lattice Crust
$31.00 -
Dutch Peach
$32.00 -
Peach Blueberry Lattice Crust
$32.00 -
Dutch Peach Blueberry
$33.00 -
Peach Praline
$34.00 -
Pineapple Lattice Crust
$28.00 -
Dutch Pineapple
$29.00 -
Black Raspberry Lattice Crust
$37.00 -
Dutch Black Raspberry
$38.00 -
Red Raspberry “Kisser” Lattice Crust
$35.00 -
Dutch Red Raspberry “Kisser”
$36.00 -
Rhubarb Lattice Crust
$31.00 -
Dutch Rhubarb
$32.00 -
Strawberry Lattice Crust
$31.00 -
Dutch Strawberry
$32.00 -
Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice Crust
$33.00 -
Dutch Strawberry Rhubarb
$34.00
Other Favorites
-
Brownie Pie
$34.00 -
Confetti Birthday Pie-Pink
$34.00 -
Confetti Birthday Pie-White
$34.00 -
Mint Chocolate Chip
$32.00 -
Pumpkin Praline
$34.00 -
Red Velvet Pie
$34.00 -
S’more Pie
$32.00 -
Chocolate Chip “I Love You”
$30.00 -
My Kentucky Pie
$36.00 -
Key Lime Graham Cracker Crust
$34.00 -
Key Lime Pastry Crust
$33.00 -
Pecan
$34.00 -
Pumpkin
$32.00 -
Hoosier Sugar Cream
$32.00